Friday, April 26, 2013

A Clean Well-Lighted Place Analysis


There are several similarities and differences between the story and the film adaption.  Some of the changes made were for the better, while others were for the worse.  I think that the setting should have been different inside the bar, but I liked how when the old man left he walked into darkness with only one light.

The setting in the film adaption was disappointing not only because it did not look like a bar, but also because the old man was inside instead of outside on the patio.  The old man was supposed to be sitting in the shadows, but since he was inside a very light place, there were hardly any shadow to put him in.

I liked the symbolism as the man walked into the dark with only one light to lead him.  It means that he has only one option and no others.  Also it could symbolize that he is going back to his life of depression, sadness and loss.

No comments:

Post a Comment